Recruiting
Create and Run a Structured Interview Kit
Candidates are evaluated consistently against the same job-related evidence, with independent scorecards completed before group discussion.
The process
Work it in this order.
- Map each approved scorecard attribute to the interview stage best suited to collect evidence for it.
- Write the same core questions for every candidate, plus allowed follow-up prompts and evidence anchors for strong, mixed, and weak responses.
- Assign interviewer roles, remove redundant questions, and train interviewers on the rubric, note-taking, accommodations, and prohibited topics.
- Share a consistent candidate agenda and collect any accommodation needs through the approved process.
- Conduct interviews using the core questions while allowing job-relevant follow-ups; record behavioral evidence rather than personality impressions.
- Require each interviewer to submit an independent scorecard before seeing peers' ratings or joining the debrief.
- Audit completion and scoring patterns, then improve unclear questions or anchors without retroactively changing individual ratings.
Bring this
Inputs the cat will ask for.
- Approved scorecard
- Interview stages and panel
- Role-specific evidence anchors
- Candidate scheduling and accommodation process
Router + one playbook
Route first. Choose one.
Cat Paw loads one playbook per task rather than merging several. Start with this router; the remaining paths are workflow-specific candidates it can inspect.
- Router:
product-pack skills/product/pm-product-discovery/interview-script/SKILL.mdskills/product/pm-toolkit/review-resume/SKILL.md
Guardrails
The boundaries travel with the prompt.
- Ask only job-related questions and avoid protected personal topics.
- Provide reasonable accommodations through the authorized process.
- Do not let interviewers view peer scores before submitting their own.
- Restrict candidate notes and recordings to approved systems and retention rules.
Done means
A checkable finish.
Every completed interview has an independently submitted evidence-based scorecard for assigned attributes, and no candidate advances to debrief with missing required feedback.
Sources
Where this process came from.
- support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/360039539772-Structured-hiring-guide
- support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/4414777492891-Scorecard-overview
Sources establish the workflow pattern. Reddit and community posts, where present, are treated as practitioner anecdotes rather than universal facts.